Ledford i present here a puzzle that arises in the area of overlap among the philosophy of logic, the philosophy of mathematics, and the philosophy of language. Han on erikoistunut kielifilosofiaan, metafysiikkaan ja logiikan filosofiaan. For example the color that cloudless skies at noon are instances of may refer to some other color in other possible world. Metaphysics, mathematics, and meaning and content, cognition, and communication both published by oxford. Michael cohen, university college ofnorth wales, bangor. My second book, freges puzzle ridgeview, 1986, 1991, belongs more squarely in the. Nathan salmon, reference and essence, in canadian journal of philosophy,14, sept.
His view, based in part of views dating back to his book reference and essence, is that there is an extensi on to be had, one which allows the application of the standard kripk ean chara cterization o f rigidity to be appl ied to both so rts of terms. Iii, theory of fields and galois theory herstein, i. Never question with our deal, due to the fact that we will consistently offer what you need. Reference and essence, philosophical investigations 10. Curriculum vitae bernard linsky december 8, 2016 address. Singular propositions trenton merricks reason, metaphysics, and mind. Let us name the possible individual who would have developed from the union of sperm s and egg e, if s had fertilized e in the normal manner, noman. Midlarge market eb account manager october 17, 2019. In this paper i will question this latter agreement.
The four worlds paradox is salmons name for his version of a puzzle, first. Oct 16, 2014 causal theories of reference for natural kind terms are widely agreed to play a central role in arguments for the claim that theoretical identity statements such as water is h2o are necessary, if true. Wholes, parts, and numbers the fifth philosophical perspectives lecture nathan salmon university of california, santa barbara if its not one thing, its two. Pdf on dec 1, 1979, nathan ucuzoglu salmon and others published how not to derive essentialism from the theory of reference find, read and cite all the research. In 1923, the journal was incorporated in the state of new york under its present name.
My second book, freges puzzle ridgeview, 1986, 1991, belongs. View nathan salmons profile on linkedin, the worlds largest professional community. In 1954 hilary putnam proposed that standard composi. Pdf how not to derive essentialism from the theory of reference. The very idea of material constitution lynne rudder baker. However, there is also fairly widespread agreement, due to the arguments of nathan salmon in reference and essence, that causal theories of reference do not alone establish such essentialism about natural kinds. What does it mean to ask if existence is a property. Myth and history in william carlos williams, jay wright, and nicolas guillen 1986 olga sofferbobyshev the upper paleolithic of the central russian plain 1985 charles e. What exactly are substances, and how do we arrive at our modal intuitions pretheoretic. Salmon syntyi sukujuuriltaan espanjanturkkilaiseen sefardijuutalaiseen perheeseen. All that we must assume is that a threshold must existthat, loosely. The book is divided into four thematic sections, on direct reference, apriority, belief, and the distinction between semantics and pragmatics. This amounts to the controversial assumption that names do not function as what nathan salmon has called obstinately rigid designators salmon 1981, 34. Indeed, the ontological argument is useful as a vehicle by which this.
Alfred 0 is not an ndimensional object, for any finite n. Nathan salmon in this new edition of an important work in the philosophy of language, nathan u salmon, one of the leading proponents of what has come to be called the new or causal theory of reference, presents his latest thinking on this promising area of study. Identity and essence, in canadian journal of philosophy, 12, june 1982, 391407. While aristotle, hume, and kants related reasons for the thesis have persuaded some, the dominant force behind this agreement is the thought, developed most forcefully in russell 1905b, that denying that existence is a firstorder. A causal theory of reference is a theory of how terms acquire specific referents based on evidence. But this is a further speculative idea to be explored.
The graduate center, the city university of new york established in 1961, the graduate center of the city university of new york cuny is devoted primarily to doctoral studies and awards most of cunys doctoral degrees. Nathan ucuzoglu salmon 1979 journal of philosophy 76 12. An internationally recognized center for advanced studies and a national model for public doctoral education, the graduate center offers more than thirty. Salmon is an american philosopher in the analytic tradition, specializing in metaphysics, philosophy of language, and philosophy of logic. Home evening star books reference and essence reference and essence. According to the modal view, essence admits of reductive analysis in exclusively modal terms. Reference and essence by nathan salmon first edition. Wittgensteins logical atomism stanford encyclopedia of.
The following argument, offered by nathan salmon, suggests that it cannot be. My work pursues especially perplexing issues and problems in metaphysics through the investigation of language. In 1984, the council of graduate schools awarded him the gustave o. Nathan salmon subscribed to a channel 2 months ago paul davids channel.
Reference and essence studies in analytic philosophy 9781591022152. Essentialism, semantic theory, and natural kinds oxford. In fact, the number of dimensions of alfred 0s spread does not stop at six. Folk building and social change in an appalachian community 1984 nathan u. Fine, basic hypergeometric series and applications askey, richard, bulletin new series of the american mathematical society, 1989. The book is divided into four thematic sections, on direct reference, apriority, belief, and. Chief among these problems is that of true singular negative existentials. On deriving essentialism from the theory of reference core. As nathan salmon pointed out years ago, we believe. August 2008 philosophy 465 philosophy of language course syllabus instructor. Against what kripkes naming and necessity might have induced us to believe, salmons reference and essence argues that essentialism cannot be derived from the direct theory of reference. Many of the issues can be organized around the following two questions.
The journal of philosophy was founded in 1904 as the journal of philosophy, psychology, and scientific methods by frederick j. See salmon, nathan, reference and essence princeton, n. A striking feature of contemporary thought, mainly due to the kripkeputnam theory of reference, is the rehabilitation of the notion of essence. The four worlds paradox doug shaver june 18, 2010 the four. Existence raises deep and important problems in metaphysics, philosophy of language, and philosophical logic. Salmon was assistant professor of philosophy at princeton university from 1978 to 1982. A fun and inspiring guitar channel, dedicated to keep the guitar fresh and alive. Nathan salmon may 2006 curriculum vitae page 5 preface to the korean translation of reference and essence, korean translation by joonho park korea. View the profiles of professionals named nathan salmon on linkedin. Nathan salmon presents a selection of nineteen of his essays from the early 1980s to 2006, on a set of closely connected topics central to analytic philosophy.
In the case of names, for example, a causal theory of reference typically involves the following claims. Son premier livre, reference and essence sa these, est couronnee par le gustave o. Nathan salmon university of california, santa barbara i among the most perennial of philosophical problems are those arising from sentences involving nonreferring names. However, there is also fairly widespread agreement, due to the arguments of nathan salmon in reference and essence, that causal theories of reference do not alone establish such. Philosophy 465 philosophy of language course syllabus. Nathan u salmon, one of the leading proponents of what has come to be called the new or causal theory of reference, presents his latest thinking on this promising area of study. The four worlds paradox doug shaver june 18, 2010 the. How not to derive essentialism from the theory of reference. Add to cart buy now reference and essence by salmon, nathan. As nathan salmon in reference and essence 1982, 51, and in can general terms are rigid.
Bush became associated with the journal as coeditor. Singular propositions about individuals that never existed nathan salmon says. However, there is also fairly widespread agreement, due to the arguments of nathan salmon in reference and essence, that causal theories of reference do not alone. Examination of the classical theories of meaning and. Nathan salmon is distinguished professor of philosophy at the university of california, santa barbara. Arlt award in the humanities, for his book, reference and essence 1981, which was based on his ucla doctoral dissertation. Essence, plenitude, and paradox 281 we allow that the n 20 condition figures in an admissible essence, it will be utterly arbitrary not to allow there are many such essences in the offing. Such theories have been used to describe many referring terms, particularly logical terms, proper names, and natural kind terms. How not to derive essentialism from the theory of reference, the journal of philosophy, 7612, 703725.
King,8 nathan salmon,9 and scott soames,10 among others. Nathan jacobson, lectures in abstract algebra, vol. My first book, reference and essence princeton university press and basil blackwell, 1982, deals with a nest of issues in an area of overlap between the. If the address matches an existing account you will receive an email with instructions to retrieve your username.
My first book, reference and essence princeton university press and basil blackwell, 1982, deals with a nest of issues in an area of overlap between the philosophy of language and metaphysics. Soames is following salmons reference and essence 19822005 here. Nathan salmon, introduction to sense and reference, in harnish, pp. Note that i am not maintaining that helms thesis that proper names express properties is itself inconsistent with kripkes views on proper names. Department o philosophy, f university of lancaster. On deriving essentialism from the theory of reference. Causal theories of reference for natural kind terms are widely agreed to play a central role in arguments for the claim that theoretical identity statements such as water is h2o are necessary, if true. Perhaps there is an unexemplified essence e, a sperm cell and an egg an actually existent sperm cell and egg, that being the only kind there are such that if that sperm. As like this upgraded book reference and essence, by nathan u. Mellor, this chapter argues that natural kind essentialism of the type advocated by kripke and putnam is not an inevitable consequence of the adoption of an antidescriptivist semantic theory of natural kind terms. Nathan salmon department of philosophy uc santa barbara.
Related essays personal identity by chad vance the nonidentity problem by duncan purves the ethics of abortion by nathan nobis. Noman does not exist in the actual world, but there are many possible worlds in. It attempts to clarify various issues about the characteristics of natural kind essentialism and its relation to semantic theory, as well as. Salmon reference and essence 1983 david pike german writers in soviet exile 19331945. Nathan salmon, reference and essence princeton, nj. First, the step leading from 2 to 3 relies on the assumption that a name fails to refer with respect to a possible world at which its actualworld referent does not exist.
215 638 922 973 478 1265 593 797 354 1094 1038 1267 1186 480 781 1154 169 21 887 1281 1513 100 817 891 584 497 1078 422 592 505 1452 243 741 999